In Seoul, A Plastic Surgery Capital, Residents Frown On Ads For Cosmetic Procedure

Feb 5, 2018
Originally published on April 2, 2018 7:04 am

In Gangnam, the upscale Seoul district south of the Han River bisecting the city, one of the area's biggest industries is evident on people's faces: On the streets, patients are wearing nose guards and bandages, fresh from facial fix-ups. High-rises soar with a cosmetic surgery clinic on every floor, and in the subway stations, floor-to-ceiling advertisements feature images of women's uniformly wide-eyed, youthful faces — all with the message that you, too, can look this way if you go to the right clinic.

South Korea has the highest per capita rate of cosmetic surgery in the world, by one key industry estimate. Gallup Korea found about one in three South Korean women between the ages of 19 and 29 said they've gone under the knife, though some counts put the number even higher. Most of the surgeries are eyelid procedures and the vast majority of plastic surgery patients are women.

Cosmetic surgery "is not even a question, a moral question — is it good, is it bad? It simply is," says Heather Willoughby, a professor of women's and cultural studies at Seoul's Ewha Womans University.

Cosmetic surgery tourism attracts so many people — mostly from Japan and China — that Seoul's Incheon airport at one point considered putting a plastic surgery clinic inside a terminal so travelers wouldn't have to go into the city to finish their procedures. (That proposal was scrapped after opposition from doctors).

But Koreans are starting to question the proliferation of cosmetic procedures. In response to a growing number of complaints from riders, the Seoul Metro, which runs the capital's public bus and subway system, announced in November that it will ban advertisements for plastic surgery at its stations.

In response to an NPR request, a Metro spokesman shared a few of the public complaints it has received:

"Please regulate large ad displays of makeovers through plastic surgeries ... It's unpleasant to see them in public spaces."

"Do more strict screening of ads that excessively promote surgery and aggravate discrimination against women."

"Advertisements that sexually objectify and commercialize women are uncomfortable to look at. Please do not authorize advertisements that reject gender equality."

Seoul Metro says the number of complaints has ticked up steadily since 2015, prompting it to take action.

But Willoughby says the problem is much broader.

"Much of the ideal [beauty] is industrialized. It's being created by the beauty industry, by K-pop [Korean pop music], by perhaps even the government, in what they're selling to the rest of the world as to the ideal Korean beauty," she says.

Bora Ki, who rushes past cosmetic surgery ads every day, calls them "horrible."

"All of the women look the same," Ki says. "So I think it's not positive."

The sameness she mentions is striking. Willoughby says it reflects the standard beauty ideal prized by Koreans: ivory skin, big, round eyes with the Western-looking double eyelid and a V-line jaw.

"There's just a sense that to conform, to be part of that norm, you have to look a certain way, act a certain way," Willoughby says.

Kim Sook-in, who makes her living as a porcelain artist, doesn't question cosmetic surgery or the prolific ads promoting it.

"It's every woman's desire to become prettier, so I think it's a good thing," Kim says.

Willoughby says Seoul residents — especially younger women and girls — could stand to see fewer reminders about how much looks matter.

"When young girls see this over and over and over, they subconsciously are told they have to be a certain way. So seeing less of it or seeing a greater diversity is a much better and much healthier thing," she says.

These ads are on their way out — but not anytime soon. Because of existing ad buys, the Metro says it doesn't expect to phase out all the subway's gleaming plastic surgery promotions until 2022.

Seoul bureau assistant Se Eun Gong contributed to this story.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

NOEL KING, HOST:

By some counts, 1 in 3 South Korean women over the age of 18 has had cosmetic surgery. But images that promote plastic surgery are starting to spark some backlash in the capital, Seoul. NPR's Elise Hu has the story.

ELISE HU, BYLINE: In Seoul's Gangnam district, there's an area known as the Improvement Quarter. Above ground are 10-story buildings where plastic surgery clinics are on every floor. Women walk up and down the sidewalk with bandages on their faces and nose guards on, fresh from new facial fix ups. And below ground, in the subway stations, you can't look in any direction without finding a floor to ceiling image of a woman's face staring back at you advertising cosmetic surgery.

I'm with our interpreter, Seyun (ph). So Seyun, this woman is staring at me, and then she appears to be saying something in Hangul. What is she saying?

SEYUN: All the pretty girls know.

HU: All the pretty girls know about BK Plastic Surgery. OK. Now I have two women staring at me. And what is the promise of this ad?

SEYUN: Harmony of eyes, nose and facial line.

HU: Harmony. OK. And then behind us is another one, called, MVP Plastic Surgery. And what does MVP sell here?

SEYUN: Touch-up surgeries are MVP Plastic Surgery Clinic.

HU: So if you're not pleased with the first job, you go to MVP to make it even better?

Making yourself prettier is a way of life in South Korea.

HEATHER WILLOUGHBY: It's not even a question, a moral question, is it good, is it bad? It simply is.

HU: Heather Willoughby, a women in cultural studies professor at Seoul's Ewha University, has lived here for nearly 15 years.

WILLOUGHBY: Much of the ideal is industrialized. It's being created by the beauty industry, by K-pop, by perhaps even the government, in what they're selling to the rest of the world as the ideal Korean beauty.

HU: But there are signs that all the signs selling surgeries are no longer so welcome. The Seoul Metro is beginning a ban on cosmetic surgery ads in the subway system. It comes in response to a rising level of complaints from riders. Bora Ki (ph), who rushes past these ads every day, says they're the worst.

BORA KI: I think they kind of seem horrible (laughter).

HU: Horrible? Why?

KI: Because you guys can see, all of these women look the same. So I think it's not positive (laughter).

HU: The sameness, she mentions, of the women in the ads is striking. Willoughby says it reflects the one standard beauty ideal that's prized here - ivory-white skin, big, round eyes with the Western-looking double eyelid and a V-line jaw.

WILLOUGHBY: Idealized beauty, I think, is very strong. There's just a sense that to conform, to be part of that norm, that you have to look a certain way, you act a certain way.

HU: Another subway rider, Kim Sook-in (ph), who makes her living as a porcelain artist, doesn't question cosmetic surgery or the prolific ads promoting it.

KIM SOOK-IN: (Through interpreter) It's every woman's desire to become prettier so I think it's a good thing.

HU: Despite some disagreement among South Koreans, Willoughby says Seoulites could stand to see fewer reminders about how much looks matter.

WILLOUGHBY: When young girls in particular see this over and over and over, they subconsciously are told they have to be a certain way. So seeing less of it, or seeing a greater diversity, is a much better and much healthier thing.

HU: These ads are on their way out, but not all that soon. The Metro says it doesn't expect to phase out all the subways' gleaming plastic surgery promotions until 2022. Elise Hu, NPR News, Seoul. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.