It's All Politics
2:59 am
Thu August 22, 2013

Future Historians: Good Luck Sifting Through Obama Video

Originally published on Thu August 22, 2013 12:43 pm

President Obama's second term is just 7 months old, but people in the White House are already starting to look at what happens when it ends.

A massive archiving project is already underway: Letters, photos and even scribbled to-do lists with doodles in the margins go to the National Archives and eventually on to the Obama presidential library.

But one part of the project is a unique challenge for this presidency: dealing with all the footage filmed by the White House videographer.

While a photographer has been an official part of the White House staff since John F. Kennedy was president, an official videographer is something new.

Arun Chaudhary spent the entire 2008 campaign and the first two years of the administration filming Obama behind the scenes.

"We are definitely talking about thousands and thousands of hours," he says, "and that's just ... my camera."

Chaudhary and his successors have filmed Obama on the basketball court, in the Oval Office and palling around with Elena Kagan seconds before he nominated her to the Supreme Court.

Military videographers have long filmed official White House events, like speeches and ceremonies. So, for example, this video of Obama speaking Portuguese to an audience in Brazil is the sort of thing that would be part of any presidential record:

But now there's also video showing the president practicing those phrases backstage before the speech — asking a young woman if he's going to make a fool of himself and saying it'll be her fault if he gets the words wrong:

"The difference between me and the military folks," Chaudhary says, "is that I'm getting a lot of this backstage material that previously wasn't official."

It all seems appropriate for the social media age, when even the most ordinary moments get preserved for posterity. But Chaudhary, who chronicled his time filming the president in a book called First Cameraman, has started to worry about what will happen to all of these White House home movies when Obama leaves office.

While the material will go to the National Archives and eventually to the Obama presidential library, Chaudhary says there are crucial differences between official and casual events that make his material much harder to search.

"I could put the text of a speech into a file or something next to the video of the speech ... and then when you're searching for a specific line, it can come up," he says. "But to actually have someone transcribe every casual conversation the president had with anyone while I was filming, I can tell you would take a long time."

Those transcripts don't exist, and nobody plans to create them. The behind-the-scenes footage is labeled by date and place. But beyond that, the contents will remain a mystery until someone combs through and catalogs them.

"The style of videography and the type of material I was capturing gives so much valuable context to these more easily searchable events, so I think it's what will be lost when someone is making a documentary in the future," Chaudhary says.

He's not the only one who's worried about this. Journalists, political scientists and filmmakers share his concern.

Martha Joynt Kumar, a political scientist at Towson University, has devoted her career to chronicling the White House.

"I first started coming into the White House when Gerald Ford was president," she says.

She relies heavily on presidential libraries for her research. And she says candid video could be a vital tool for understanding a presidency.

"A videographer is going to take pictures where you actually see the president's interactions — and that's something you really want to get a sense of," she says.

Sharon Fawcett, who ran the presidential library system for the National Archives until retiring two years ago, says this kind of material has the potential to illuminate a presidency in new ways.

"I think it's hugely important," she says. "Having this video diary with this information in it will be a great source for future historians to find out what the president was thinking and how his thinking may have evolved, what kind of conversations he was having with people."

That's if the video becomes easily usable. People who work on these issues dream of a Google-style video search that will let people comb through footage looking for, say, any mention of health care or any time a specific person appears.

Chaudhary says tech geniuses have spent years trying and failing to solve this puzzle.

"Search engine optimization with video is very, very hard," he says. "Finding videos you're looking for is very, very hard, and in terms of sort of digital stuff, it's this real holy grail. People talk about it all the time."

So it's not just a government problem. Chaudhary says if YouTube had this cracked, we'd know about it.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

Only seven months into President Obama's second term in office, but there are people in the White House starting to look at what happens when it ends. A massive archiving project is already underway. Letters, photos and even scribbled to-do lists with doodles in the margins go to the National Archives and eventually on to the Obama Presidential Library.

NPR's Ari Shapiro reports on one part of this project that's a unique challenge for this presidency.

ARI SHAPIRO, BYLINE: A photographer has been an official part of the White House staff since John F. Kennedy was president, but a White House videographer is something new.

(SOUNDBITE OF VIDEO)

PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Arun, why are you filming me now.

SHAPIRO: That's President Obama shouting at Arun Chaudhary, who spent the entire 2008 campaign and the first two years of the administration filming Barack Obama behind the scenes.

ARUN CHAUDHARY: We are definitely talking about thousands and thousands of hours, and that's just, you know, just my camera.

SHAPIRO: Chaudhary and his successors have filmed Obama on the basketball court, in the Oval Office and pal-ing around with Elena Kagan seconds before he nominated her to the Supreme Court.

(SOUNDBITE OF VIDEO)

OBAMA: Just don't trip. That will be really embarrassing.

SHAPIRO: Military videographers have long filmed official White House events. Every speech and ceremony has been recorded and catalogued. So for example, this video of President Obama speaking Portuguese to an audience in Brazil is the sort of thing that would have been part of any presidential record.

(SOUNDBITE OF VIDEO)

OBAMA: (Speaking foreign language)

SHAPIRO: But now there's also video showing the president backstage practicing those phrases before the speech, asking a young woman if he's going to make a fool of himself and saying it'll be her fault if he gets the words wrong.

(SOUNDBITE OF VIDEO)

OBAMA: (Speaking foreign language) Is that good? Okay. I'm not going to make a fool of myself. It'll be your fault.

CHAUDHARY: The difference between me and the military folks is that I'm getting a lot of this backstage material that previously wasn't official.

SHAPIRO: It all seems appropriate for the social media age, when even the most ordinary moments get preserved for posterity. But Arun Chaudhary has started to worry about what will happen to all of these White House home movies when President Obama leaves office. The material will go to the Archives and eventually to the Obama Presidential Library, but Chaudhary says there are crucial differences between official and casual events that make his material much harder to search.

CHAUDHARY: Because I could put the text of a speech into a file or something next to the video of the speech, right? And then when you're searching for a specific line, it can come up. But to actually have someone transcribe every casual conversation the president had with anyone while I was filming, I can tell you would take a long time.

SHAPIRO: The behind-the-scenes footage is labeled by date and place. But beyond that, the contents will remain a mystery until someone combs through and catalogs them.

CHAUDHARY: The style of videography and the type of material I was capturing gives so much valuable context to these more easily searchable events, so I think it's what will be lost when someone is making a documentary in the future.

SHAPIRO: He's not the only one who's worried about this. Journalists, political scientists and filmmakers share his concern. Martha Joynt Kumar is a political scientist at Towson University who has devoted her career to chronicling the White House.

MARTHA JOYNT KUMAR: I first started coming into the White House when Gerald Ford was president.

SHAPIRO: She relies heavily on presidential libraries for her research. And she says candid video could be a vital tool for understanding a presidency.

KUMAR: A videographer is going to take pictures where you actually see the president's interactions, and that's something you really want to get a sense of.

SHAPIRO: Sharon Fawcett agrees. She ran the presidential library system for the National Archives until retiring two years ago.

SHARON FAWCETT: I think it's hugely important. Having this video diary with this information in it will be a great source for future historians to find out what the president was thinking and how his thinking may have evolved, what kind of conversations he was having with people.

SHAPIRO: That's if the video becomes easily usable. People who work on these issues dream of a Google-style video search that will let people comb through footage looking for, say, any mention of health care or any time a specific person appears. Arun Chaudhary says tech geniuses have spent years trying and failing to solve this puzzle.

CHAUDHARY: Search engine optimization with video is very, very hard. Finding videos you're looking for is very, very hard, and in terms of sort of digital stuff, it's this real holy grail. People talk about it all the time.

SHAPIRO: So it's not just a government problem. Chaudhary says if YouTube had this cracked, we'd know about it. Ari Shapiro, NPR News, the White House. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Related Program